Option #2 is going to get you a lot further with your guy than putting his back up against a wall and ordering him to do something that’s probably not going to make him happy anyway. When you approach him with love, whatever you want becomes something inviting and appealing, but when you give him an ultimatum and tell him he has to do something, suddenly you’ve become like his mother scolding him when he was younger. Words matter because they decide whether he feels led or controlled.